10 Comments
User's avatar
Harvey Stanbrough's avatar

Frank, I don't advocate never reading any how-to books, but I do STRONGLY advise avoiding those that say the same old thing all the others say. Dean's books don't mimic the myth-spouting how-tos, and neither do mine.

Expand full comment
Frank Theodat's avatar

I typically shy away from certain authors who keep the myths alive. That's what makes selecting how-to books quite difficult. You, Dean, and Mr. Bedford-Jones are aligned in that fiction is personal, fun, and can be rewarding so long as we allow our creative voice freedom to play in the fiction sandbox. It was refreshing to see the lessons I learned from you and Dean vindicated from a book in 1922.

Expand full comment
Harvey Stanbrough's avatar

Yup. The good stuff remains good and is passed along, albeit to seemingly fewer and fewer serious writers in each generation.

Expand full comment
Michael Howlett's avatar

Thanks Frank! I think I'm suitably motivated to hammer out some words today after reading this!

Expand full comment
Terry Freedman's avatar

I like the idea of "hack writing". I write really fast myself, and I'm prolific. I often jokingly refer to my "bashing out an article" but I do. I don't do shitty first drafts either, so this HBJ person and his book sound great, and just up my street even though I don't write fiction (apart from my to-do list). Thanks for such an insightful review, which I've restacked!

Expand full comment
Frank Theodat's avatar

Thanks Terry. Much appreciated!

Expand full comment
Terry Freedman's avatar

A pleasure, Frank.

Expand full comment
Vincent Zandri's avatar

Great stuff Frank!

Expand full comment
Clintavo's avatar

“The rules are there ain’t no rules” - Leo of the Scorpians to Danny Zuko before the race at Thunder Road.

Expand full comment
Edward Rooster's avatar

100%, This is wisdom I relate to, I'm glad you "broke" your own decision about what to read at the moment, Frank, thanks for sharing these gems from an old Master.

Expand full comment